The global shift towards a just energy transition is accelerating, with Africa positioned as a major supplier of critical minerals needed for renewable energy technologies. However, a fundamental question remains unanswered: Energy transition for whom? This was the theme for the 2025 Alternative Mining Indaba (AMI) that happened from the 3-6th of February in Cape Town and a central part of TrustAfrica’s session during the Idea Lab at AMI 2025. Speakers and participants critically examined the power dynamics, economic realities, and social justice issues embedded in Africa’s role in the transition. The discussion focused on the key role of national, community and media stakeholders to highlight the challenges of the sector in the energy transition and if there is a room for communities to be involved in defining the energy transition for their community.
A Call for Action: What Needs to Change?

Briggs Bomba set the tone for the discussion by urging participants to interrogate what the critical questions are for Africa and its communities in this discourse. While the transition away from fossil fuels is necessary, it must not exacerbate existing inequalities or further entrench Africa’s role as a raw material exporter with no control over its wealth. He asked critical questions for reflection; The role of fossil fuel in the interim? How do we build capacities for Communities to become a social force?
Financing for development emerged as a major concern. Governments are prioritizing Foreign Direct Investments (FDI) that often lead to debt distress, rather than seeking sustainable financing mechanisms that empower local economies. This links to the larger issue of illicit financial flows (IFFs), where investments serve as channels for siphoning wealth out of the continent rather than creating genuine economic benefits.
The session also highlighted the social and environmental costs of irresponsible mining. The destruction of water bodies, land degradation, and displacement of communities undermines food security and other revenue sources like agriculture. Francis Opoku, a miner from Ghana and the financial secretary of the ASM associaciation shared the lived experiences and challenges of miners. In Ghana alone, over 1 million people work directly in Artisanal and Small-scale Mining (ASM, with 5 million benefiting indirectly. Rather than criminalizing the sector, governments must support and formalize ASM, providing training on responsible mining and ensuring social protections. He noted that it is important for miners to be part of decision making. ‘If we are the problem, we should be allowed to be part of the solution’
Gender and social equity are also critical. Women and indigenous communities are disproportionately affected by land grabs, dislocation, and violations of land rights in mining areas. Without explicit policies to protect these groups, the energy transition risks deepening exclusion and worsening vulnerabilities.
Erastus Asare Donkor, an investigative journalist, shared the challenges of reporting on mining injustices, including threats, attacks, and even physical assault for exposing illegal activities. Despite these risks, the media remains an essential force in demanding accountability and amplifying community voices. The session was an interractive one which allowed participants to share their experiences and recommendations.
A Call for Action: What Needs to Change?
The session generated concrete recommendations for policymakers, industry leaders, and civil society to ensure Africa’s role in the energy transition is fair, sustainable, and beneficial to its people:
- Demand traceability mechanisms for all critical minerals to include both social and environmental standards.
- Technology transfer and local training must be central to any investment deals, ensuring that African workers gain the skills to move beyond extraction into value addition.
- Support for the UN Tax Convention is crucial to increasing Africa’s control over its tax regime and stopping revenue loss through IFFs and tax evasion.
- Beneficiation must be community-focused, ensuring that resource extraction benefits local economies, not just multinational corporations.
- Formalizing ASM should be a priority, with policies that enable small-scale miners to operate legally and sustainably.
- States must prioritize local entities, creating an enabling environment for African-owned mining enterprises instead of favoring foreign multinationals.


A Call for Action: What Needs to Change?
Civil society organizations have a critical role in ensuring that the energy transition is truly just and equitable. The session emphasized three key areas where civil society must act:
- Building the capacity of communities to organize, mobilize, and advocate for the transition they want. As one speaker put it, “Whatever the question, community is the answer!”
- Connecting the struggles by linking movements across sectors, from agrarian rights to, debt and tax justice, recognizing that these issues are interconnected.
- Supporting investigation and investigative journalists at the forefront of exposing injustices in the mining sector, ensuring they have the resources and protection to promote transparency and accountability.

Africa’s minerals must not fuel another era of exploitation while leaving local communities behind. The energy transition must be African-led, community-centered, and justice-driven. Governments, industry players, and civil society must work together to redefine investment, enforce responsible mining, and protect marginalized communities.
As the session concluded, one sentiment was clear: The fight for a just transition is not just about minerals it is about power, justice, and the future of Africa’s people.






